Heat pumps for homes without natural gas: propane or electric heat vs a heat pump

No natural gas line? Compare a propane furnace, electric resistance heat and a cold-climate heat pump, plus dual fuel with propane backup.
Without natural gas, your main choices are a propane furnace, electric resistance heat, or a heat pump. A heat pump can also pair with a propane furnace as backup. The fit depends on your home, ducts and bills.
Homes outside a gas company's lines still need reliable heat for a Colorado winter. This guide compares the options side by side, explains how a heat pump can work with propane backup, covers the rebates that may apply and shows how we help you decide. Our Northern Colorado HVAC page covers the systems we install.
What are the options if your home has no natural gas line?
There are four common setups: a propane furnace, electric resistance heat, a heat pump on its own, or a heat pump with a propane furnace as backup. Each can heat a home; they differ in fuel, running cost and upkeep.
- A propane furnace. Works like a natural gas furnace but burns propane from a tank on your property. You arrange fuel deliveries.
- Electric resistance heat. Baseboard heaters or an electric furnace. Simple, but it turns electricity straight into heat.
- A heat pump. One HVAC system that heats and cools by moving heat instead of burning fuel. It can be ducted, or ductless for homes without ducts.
- Dual fuel. A heat pump that handles most of the year, with a propane furnace that takes over on the coldest days.
How does a heat pump compare with a propane furnace?
A heat pump heats and cools with one system and needs no fuel deliveries. A propane furnace only heats, needs a tank and deliveries, and usually still needs a separate AC. Running cost depends on your propane and electric rates.
How each one makes heat
A heat pump uses outdoor air as its heat source in winter and moves that heat inside. A propane furnace burns fuel to make heat. Cold climates need heat pumps specially designed to keep running at lower outdoor temperatures, and cold-climate heat pumps are rated to keep heating well below freezing.
What it means for you
- Cooling: a heat pump cools like an AC. A propane furnace needs a separate AC for summer.
- Fuel: a heat pump runs on electricity. Propane means a tank, deliveries and watching the gauge in winter.
- Efficiency ratings: furnaces are rated by AFUE, a furnace efficiency rating. Heat pumps carry their own heating and cooling ratings.
- Running cost: it depends on what you pay for propane and for electricity, and on how well the home holds heat. We do not guess at your bill; we look at it.
Compared with electric resistance heat
Electric resistance heat is simple but inefficient. The U.S. Department of Energy notes that a heat pump's backup resistance heat is inefficient and its use should be kept to a minimum. If your home heats with baseboard or an electric furnace, a heat pump is worth comparing.
If propane is in your home, know the safety line for a gas smell. Leave your home now. From outside, call your gas company and the fire department. Then call us.
Can a heat pump use a propane furnace as backup?
Yes. A heat pump can pair with a propane furnace so the heat pump handles most of the year and the furnace backs it up on the coldest days. This setup is called dual fuel.
Many Colorado homes run a cold-climate heat pump alone, and others keep the furnace as backup for the coldest nights. Dual fuel can make sense when:
- You already have a propane furnace in good shape. Adding a heat pump can replace your AC and take over most of the heating.
- You want a backup that does not rely on electric resistance. The furnace covers the coldest stretches.
- Your propane use is high. A heat pump doing most of the work can mean fewer deliveries.
The right size for either part comes from a load calculation of your home, because square footage alone is not enough.
Which rebates may apply?
Heat pump rebates follow your electric company. Which rebate applies depends on the electric and gas company on your bill, so we check both with you.
- The Colorado heat pump tax credit may give you at least $333 off your invoice for 2026 (last verified October 1, 2026) when a registered contractor installs a qualifying heat pump.
On its own, a furnace has no rebate. Our guide to why heat pump rebates differ across Northern Colorado explains how city utilities, co-ops and other electric companies differ. To look up your own utility, use our Northern Colorado rebates page.
How do we help you decide?
With a $0 visit. We look at your current system, ducts, panel and bills, run a load calculation, and give you a written quote for the options that fit. You pay nothing for us to come out.
- Your current heat. Age, condition and how many years your current heating may have left.
- Your ducts. Ducted homes can often use a ducted heat pump. Homes without ducts can look at a ductless system.
- Your panel. Many panels can handle a heat pump, but some homes need more capacity. Because our HVAC team and master electrician work together, we check the panel as part of planning your heat pump.
- Your bills. Your electric company decides which rebate may apply, and your propane and electric rates shape running cost.
Converting from fuel to electric heat usually involves the heat pump, sometimes a panel upgrade, and often a water heater decision. We handle HVAC, electrical and plumbing in-house, so one company plans and does all of it. Before you size anything, our guide to insulation and air sealing first explains why the house itself can change the answer.
Why choose Veteran for a no-gas home?
We install cold-climate, rebate-qualifying heat pumps and check the panel with our own master electrician. That means an honest comparison, not a push toward one answer.
- An Elite Midea dealer. Every system we install meets rebate requirements.
- One company, three trades. HVAC, plumbing and electrical.
- Straight answers. Customers describe straight answers, no upselling, and a final bill that matched the quote.
Our technicians are based in Northern Colorado. Call (970) 585-7776 for a $0 visit, or see our Northern Colorado HVAC page to compare systems.
Need Help?
Contact us today to discuss your needs. Our team is ready to help.
About the Author
Founder, U.S. Army veteran
More Articles
View All PostsReady to Get Started?
Whether you need a repair, maintenance, or a new installation, our expert team is here to help.

