Skip to content
We Answer 24/7 $0 Trip Fee. Always.

Dual fuel or all-electric: do I still need a furnace with a heat pump?

Tips & Advice

Founder, U.S. Army veteran

October 30, 2026
5 min read
Dual fuel or all-electric: do I still need a furnace with a heat pump?

Not always. Compare a heat pump with furnace backup to an all-electric heat pump for a Colorado home, including how each works and how rebates differ.

Not always. Many Colorado homes run a cold-climate heat pump alone. Others keep the gas furnace as backup for the coldest nights, a setup called dual fuel. The right choice depends on your home, your ducts and your rebates.

This guide compares the two paths side by side so you can talk to any contractor with a clear picture. Our heat pump installation page describes how we plan and install either one.

Do I still need a furnace if I install a heat pump?

Not always. Many Colorado homes run a cold-climate heat pump alone, because cold-climate models are rated to keep heating well below freezing. Keeping a furnace is an option, not a rule.

A heat pump moves heat instead of burning fuel to make it. In winter it pulls heat from outdoor air and moves it inside. In summer it runs the other way and cools your home like an AC. A cold-climate heat pump is a type built to keep doing that job on very cold days.

So the question is not "will it work?" It is "which setup fits my home and my budget best over time?" That is where the two paths split.

What is dual fuel?

Dual fuel pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace. The heat pump handles heating and cooling for most of the year. The furnace backs it up on the coldest days. Both share the same ducts and one thermostat.

What is all-electric?

An all-electric setup uses the heat pump as the main heat source with no gas furnace. Some all-electric systems also include electric backup heat in the indoor unit for the coldest hours.

How does a dual fuel system decide which one runs?

The thermostat or control board switches between them. Above a set outdoor temperature, the heat pump runs. Below it, or when the house cannot keep up, the furnace takes over. Only one heats at a time.

That switch point is a setting, not a fixed number. It is chosen when the system is set up, based on the heat pump, the home and what the owner cares about most. Some owners want the heat pump to run as much as possible. Others prefer the furnace to take over sooner on cold nights.

  • Mild days: the heat pump heats the home, often running longer at a gentler air temperature than a furnace.
  • Cold snaps: the furnace takes the load, with the hotter supply air gas heat is known for.
  • Summer: the heat pump cools. The furnace blower moves the air.

Dual fuel also works when you already have a furnace with good years left. A heat pump can pair with your existing furnace instead of replacing it. If the furnace is old, replacing both together is often simpler.

One safety note for any home that keeps gas heat. If you smell gas: Leave your home now. From outside, call Xcel Energy and the fire department. Then call us.

When does an all-electric heat pump make sense in a Colorado home?

All-electric fits when you want to move off gas, when the furnace is at the end of its life, or when your home's size and ducts let one heat pump carry the full load comfortably.

  • You want to leave gas behind. Some owners plan a full switch to electric over time. Our guide on converting a home from gas to electric covers the steps.
  • The furnace is failing anyway. If the furnace needs replacing, skipping it in favor of a right-sized heat pump is worth comparing.
  • The house is a good match. Ducts that move enough air and a load calculation that the heat pump can meet both point to all-electric.
  • Your panel has room. An all-electric home draws more power in winter. Some homes need more panel capacity first.

Dual fuel tends to fit when the furnace is fairly new, when the home has high heating needs, or when the owner wants a gas backup they already know. Neither answer is wrong. If you want the longer either/or comparison, our post on heat pumps vs gas furnaces covers it, and navigating furnace vs heat pump upgrades looks at upgrade timing.

How do rebates differ between dual fuel and all-electric?

Both setups can qualify for heat pump rebates, but the rules can treat them differently. How much of your heat the heat pump provides, and how your home is heated today, can change what you may qualify for.

  • Xcel Energy cold-climate heat pump rebate. Xcel pays a per-ton rebate on qualifying cold-climate heat pumps. Its terms differ based on how the home is heated today (last verified October 1, 2026).
  • Colorado heat pump tax credit. You may qualify for at least $333 off your invoice for 2026 (last verified October 1, 2026). The heat pump must be ENERGY STAR certified, installed by a registered contractor, and meet at least 80% of the home's annual heating needs. A dual fuel system where the furnace does a lot of the heating may not meet that bar.
  • Power Ahead Colorado. A program for Front Range households in participating towns, with no income test (last verified October 1, 2026).

One credit you may have heard about is gone. The federal 25C tax credit ended for equipment installed after December 31, 2025, so it does not apply to a system installed now.

Rebate amounts depend on your utility, your address, the equipment and sometimes your income. We install only rebate-qualifying equipment and we file the rebate paperwork. The Denver rebates page lists each program.

How do we help you choose?

We look at your furnace, ducts and electrical panel at no charge, size the system for your house, and recommend what fits your home and your rebates. Then you decide.

  • Sized for your house. Square footage alone is not enough. Sizing also matters because the Xcel rebate is paid per ton.
  • Panel checked in-house. Our master electrician, Matthew Donizio, works with our HVAC team, so one company plans the heat pump and any panel work.
  • Cold-climate equipment. We are an Elite Midea dealer, and every system we install meets rebate requirements.
  • Covered after the install. Every new system is covered by the Veteran 1-Year Make-It-Right-or-Take-It-Back Guarantee. Conditions apply; the written guarantee is available before you buy. Read the guarantee.

Most installs take 1 to 3 days once work starts. Not sure what a heat pump does on a cold morning? Our guide to why a heat pump blows cool air in winter explains defrost mode.

Ready to compare dual fuel and all-electric for your home? Book a $0 visit through our heat pump installation page, or call (720) 722-1229. We answer 24/7, and our trip fee is always $0.

Ready to Get Started?

Whether you need a repair, maintenance, or a new installation, our expert team is here to help.