Water Heater Emergency: What to Do First, and Whether to Repair or Replace

Smell gas? Leave your home now. From outside, call your gas company and the fire department. Then call us.
A failed water heater is stressful, and a few calm steps in the right order keep it from getting worse. This guide covers which signs are urgent, what to do first for a leak, a gas unit or an electric unit, and how to decide between repair and replacement.
Is my water heater problem an emergency?
It is if the tank is leaking heavily, you smell gas, you see scorch marks or smell burning, or a breaker keeps tripping. No hot water alone is urgent, but it is not dangerous.
Call right away
- Water pooling around the base: a leak from the tank body can release a lot of water and usually means the tank is done.
- A gas smell: follow the gas line above first.
- Burning smells, scorch marks or a repeatedly tripping breaker on an electric unit, which point to an electrical fault.
- Loud banging or rumbling that is new and getting worse, which often means heavy sediment buildup in the tank.
Can wait for the schedule
- Hot water that is lukewarm, uneven or slow to heat.
- A small drip from a fitting or valve.
- Lower hot water pressure than usual.
- A sulfur smell in the water itself, with no gas smell near the unit.
Not sure which list you are on? Call. We answer 24/7, with no after-hours charges, ever. If it's a real emergency, we escalate to a manager right away and move our schedule to get you help. Everything else goes on the schedule starting at 7am. We never promise an arrival time.
What should I do first when my water heater fails?
Stop the water, cut the power to an electric unit, and keep everyone away from anything wet and electrical. Never repair gas or electrical parts yourself.
- Leak: close the cold water shutoff on the pipe feeding the heater. If you cannot find it, close the main water valve.
- Electric unit: turn off the water heater breaker at the panel, but only if you can reach it from dry floor. Do not touch a wet unit.
- Gas unit: leave the gas controls alone; we handle them. If you smell gas at any point, leave and use the gas line at the top of this page.
- Photos: take pictures of any water damage for your records.
Gas water heaters also produce carbon monoxide, an odorless, colorless gas. The CDC lists headache, dizziness, weakness, nausea and confusion as symptoms. If anyone has them, get everyone outside into fresh air and call 911.
Tell us what you see when you call: where the water is, what kind of unit it is and whether anyone is in danger. A leaking heater is a plumbing job, and our plumbers handle water heater repair on tank and tankless units, gas and electric.
Should I repair or replace my water heater?
If the tank itself is leaking, replace it. If a part like a thermostat, element or valve has failed on a younger unit, repair usually makes sense.
- Age: most tank water heaters last 8 to 12 years. An older unit with repeat problems is a poor repair bet.
- Where it leaks: fittings and the relief valve can often be repaired. A leak from the tank body cannot.
- Rust-colored water or heavy rumbling: corrosion or sediment inside the tank, both signs of a unit near the end of its life.
- Your next unit: tank, tankless or heat pump water heater. A heat pump water heater may qualify for rebates, depending on your utility and address, and we file the paperwork. See our rebates page.
We give you both options at no trip charge and tell you honestly which side yours falls on. We work with upfront, flat-rate pricing and do free estimates on any job, so you can compare a repair with a replacement before you decide.
If you replace, a new water heater we install is covered by the Veteran 1-Year Make-It-Right-or-Take-It-Back Guarantee. It does not cover repairs or maintenance. Conditions apply; the written guarantee is available before you buy. Read the 1-year guarantee.
How do I keep it from failing again?
Flush sediment, check the anode rod and have the relief valve tested. Minerals in water settle as scale when it is heated, so regular care is what extends the life of the unit.
- Flushing: draining sediment from the tank improves efficiency and quiets rumbling. Follow the manufacturer's schedule.
- Anode rod: this sacrificial rod corrodes in place of the tank. When it is used up, the tank is next.
- Temperature and pressure relief valve: a safety part that should be tested by a professional, not ignored.
- A look for leaks: check the base and the fittings for moisture or rust now and then.
For $9.99 a month, our Basic Care plan adds a yearly plumbing check that includes a water heater flush (A $99 value). The yearly checks help protect your warranty coverage, since the warranty excludes damage from lack of maintenance. For more, see our guides to how long a water heater lasts in Colorado and why water heaters rupture without warning.
Why choose Veteran when the water heater fails?
Because you need a straight answer fast. We answer 24/7, we tell you honestly whether to repair or replace, and one team covers the plumbing, gas and wiring sides of the job.
Owner Mike Townsend spent eight years in the U.S. Army managing precision cooling systems for heat-seeking missile technology, and he runs every job with the same attention to detail.
- No after-hours charges. A failure at night costs the same as one at noon, and the trip fee is always $0.
- We fix any major brand. Your heater does not have to be one we installed.
- A real repair-or-replace answer. Reviews of our work mention honest advice and no upselling, and Jimi Knight, a Colorado Master Plumber, is on staff.
- One company for the whole job. If the replacement touches gas or a circuit, our plumbers and electricians work as one team, so you do not coordinate three contractors. Start with our plumbing services.
Need help with this at your home? See our Water Heater Repair service.
Need Help?
Contact us today to discuss your needs. Our team is ready to help.
About the Author
Founder, U.S. Army veteran
More Articles
View All PostsRelated Articles

The Hidden Connection Between Back-to-School Schedule Changes and Sudden Water Heater Failures
When summer ends, staggered morning routines vanish overnight. This sudden, concentrated demand for hot showers often pushes aging water heaters to their breaking point.
Read Article
Emergency Hot Water Heater Repair: Find Services
Read Article
The Mechanical Reasons Why Water Heaters Rupture Without Warning
A flooded basement often starts with invisible galvanic corrosion and thermal expansion. Understand this hidden breakdown process to prevent a sudden water heater rupture before fall begins.
Read ArticleReady to Get Started?
Whether you need a repair, maintenance, or a new installation, our expert team is here to help.